GOVERNMENT
By Fraser Sherman
Correspondent
Can Carrboro grow a downtown where residents can meet their daily shopping needs without driving elsewhere?
Would residents prefer development that blends in with existing neighborhoods or development that provides more affordable housing?
Is a 50-year-old building a part of history?
Those were among the questions Town Council members discussed at a May 13 meeting on the town’s downtown development plan and the rewrite of the town’s land use ordinance (LUO). The meeting was intended to update the council about the ongoing work, with no decisions requiring a vote.
The downtown area plan will shape future development by establishing guidelines for public spaces, land use, streetscapes, building aesthetics, and redevelopment regulations. The town has been encouraging residents to engage and voice their opinion so that “the community being built is what the community would like to see,” Danny Wilson of the Freese and Nichols consulting firm said.
Wilson said the consultants had heard from around 580 participants at public workshops and presentations. Based on those meetings, the qualities residents most wanted to see downtown included public space, art, music, and entertainment; affordability; more greenery; easy access and better transportation; and respect for Carrboro’s historic identity.
The future of history
Council member Catherine Fray raised another topic, the preservation of historic buildings, and asked what the definition of “historic building” was.
Wilson replied that anything on the National Register or Carrboro’s historic district could qualify. “As far as historic architecture, it could just be buildings that have been here a long time.”
How long, Fray asked? Wilson replied that staff were thinking about the late 1800s and early 1900s, but “technically ‘historic’ is anything over 50 years, which puts us in the mid-1970s.”She asked about bui
“That’s a very generous definition,” Fray replied.
Fray asked about the status of historic areas where the buildings had been extensively renovated. Wilson replied that if one building on a block had been modified, that wouldn’t affect the area’s historic status, but four or five might.
Daily needs
Council member Randee Haven-O’Donnell asked how the town could encourage downtown retail to develop so that residents could shop there for everyday needs.
“The intent with downtown is daily living,” Wilson said, “businesses that help you live your life.” He said while Carrboro can’t dictate which retailers move in, there were ways to encourage “daily businesses.” Carrboro can also develop rules to help businesses stay in town when they outgrow their initial premises.
Appearance vs. affordability
Fray asked about balancing preserving a particular aesthetic compatible with neighboring property and keeping Carrboro affordable. “It’s not that we want downtown development to be insensitive to the neighboring context, but equity and anti-displacement are considerably more important.” The worst-case alternative would be to preserve the look while making downtown “a bit of a theme park, and long-time residents have moved out because they couldn’t afford to stay.”
Council Member Danny Nowell said aesthetics shouldn’t be a roadblock. Even if the look of downtown did change, “people tend to react strongly to change, then grow used to it pretty quickly.”
The unified development ordinance
Chad Meadows of Codewright Planning updated the council on the ongoing work of replacing the city’s old land use ordinance (LUO) with a new unified development ordinance (UDO). The UDO will set zoning regulations, encourage the creation of affordable housing, set stormwater and flood-management requirements for new development, set tree-preservation standards, and lay down rules for sidewalks.
Meadows told the council that part of the problem is that the existing LUO dates back to the 1980s, one of the first in North Carolina. Over the years, amendments and updates have been tacked on at the ends of the different LUO sections, making it hard to find information. The prose the LUO is written in makes it necessary “to hold six, seven ideas in your head” at once to see how the rules work.
The solutions, Meadows said, included grouping the information in 10 chapters rather than 20, using short bulleted lists of information instead of prose, and adding flow charts displaying how the city’s approval processes work. “Many things you want to do are in the code, but you can’t find them. Finding them is a challenge.”
Meadows said Codewright’s outreach to the public had found support for rules that encouraged more compact development, greater pedestrian mobility, increased recreation space in new developments, and keeping development to three to five stories.
Fray raised affordability again, asking whether the UDO would allow enough development to keep housing affordable. Meadows said several local North Carolina governments had taken steps to expand the housing supply without making it more affordable. “We’re trying to piece together why, and what we can do differently.”
Meadows also discussed various bills in the state legislature that would limit Carrboro’s ability to set its own development rules. While some of the bills appeared dead in the water, others did not, and they’d make a massive difference to downtown development and the UDO. “It’s our job to help you guys navigate these things once you become law.”
You can watch the meeting on YouTube.
Fraser Sherman has worked for newspapers, including the Destin Log, the Pensacola News-Journal and the Raleigh Public Record. Born in England, he’d still live in Florida if he hadn’t met the perfect woman and moved to Durham to marry her. He’s the author of several film reference books and has published one novel and several short story collections. This reporter can be reached at: Information@TheLocal Reporter.press






Be the first to comment on "Carrboro town council discusses downtown development, land use"