SPORTS
By Adam Powell
Correspondent
The first week of December around the local high school sports scene in Chapel Hill and Carrboro was punctuated by some rivalry matchups on the basketball court, along with some impressive individual performances on the wrestling mat. One of Carrboro’s standout wrestlers won his weight class at one of the most prestigious pre-Holiday tournaments in the region, while Chapel Hill and Carrboro faced off on the hardwood.
Take a closer look at the local basketball and wrestling action in this week’s High School Sports Notebook.

CHAPEL HILL HIGH TIGERS
Men’s Basketball: Tigers blow out Carrboro, fall to Northwood
Chapel Hill’s men’s basketball team split a pair of games on December 5 and December 6 following its 65-33 blowout of Seaforth on December 2. While the Tigers won their fourth straight with a 59-17 blowout of Carrboro on the evening of December 5, they suffered a 22-point loss to Northwood in Pittsboro on December 6.
On the road at Carrboro, Chapel Hill dominated the Jaguars with balance. A total of 12 Tigers scored in the victory, led by sophomore Makhai Manning’s 14 points. Senior Jacari Burnette added eight points, while another senior – Samuel Zimmerman – contributed six points. The Tigers made 59% of their 2-point field goal attempts in the game (22-of-37) while committing only nine turnovers. The Chapel Hill defense was aggressive, facing a total of 18 steals. Seniors Niko Davis and Juice McIlwaine were particularly effective on defense, as each picked up three steals in the win.
Unfortunately for head coach Rodney Carter’s squad, they were unable to carry the momentum of the Carrboro win into Saturday’s road tilt, as the Tigers fell 60-38 to Northwood to snap their four-game winning streak, and slip to 4-2 overall through six games.
The Tigers struggled offensively against the Chargers, making just 34% of their shot attempts for the game (13-of-38). Northwood, meanwhile, shot a healthy 54% (21-of-39) while burying a whopping nine 3-pointers on 18 attempts (50%). The Tigers committed 16 turnovers while forcing only five steals themselves. Sophomore Cole Gwaltney was the lone Tiger in double figures in scoring with 10 points, while Manning added nine points. Senior Cam Fowler led Northwood with 21 points, while junior Josiah Brown added 15 points.
Chapel Hill begins a three-game homestand to close out the pre-Holiday portion of the December schedule on Friday night. The Tigers host Heritage (3-5) at home in the CHHS gymnasium. On Saturday, Chapel Hill hosts Eastern Randolph, and then on Wednesday, December 18, the Tigers host Franklinton.
Women’s Basketball – Tigers split pair of games for 4-2 start
Like the Chapel Hill High men’s basketball team, the Tigers women’s squad won four out of its first six games to begin the 2025-26 season. Coming off a heartbreaking 49-47 road loss to regional powerhouse Seaforth on December 2 in Pittsboro, the Tigers traveled to Carrboro on December 5 – earning a dominant 60-31 victory – while suffering another devastating close loss on December 6 – this one to Cornelius Hough.
Little went wrong for the Tigers in the December 5 road game at Carrboro, as the visitors broke out to an early 15-8 lead in the first quarter. The Tigers used an 18-4 run in the second quarter to build a commanding 33-12 halftime lead, and then continued growing the lead in the second half. Leading 48-20 heading into the final period, Chapel Hill cooled off a little and let its backups finish out the local rivalry victory.
Junior Stephanie Proano led three Tigers in double figures with 12 points in the win, while freshman Kennedi Patterson contributed 11 points and senior Scarlett Gilner 10 points. Gilner and fellow senior Haara Umenwaliri each added seven rebounds as well.
On Saturday, December 6, the Tigers challenged Hough in a tough non-conference battle that should hopefully pay dividends for John French’s squad in the weeks and months to come. CHHS got off to a solid start, leading 18-12 in the first quarter. The second quarter was a plodding, defensive battle, with the game going into halftime with Chapel Hill leading, 23-17.
Chapel Hill still led, 32-27, heading into the fourth quarter, but Hough began clawing back down the stretch, eventually taking the lead and narrowly pushing past the Tigers by a single point, 44-43. Gilner led the Tigers with 14 points in the narrow loss, while Patterson and junior Ashanti McClain each had eight points.
On Friday night, Chapel Hill gets another tough non-conference challenge as they face Heritage (6-2). On December 15 the Tigers host Durham Jordan, followed by another home game December 18 against Franklinton.
The first weekend of December was a busy one for area wrestling programs, as Carrboro and East Chapel Hill made appearances at the Jim King Invitational on the campus of Orange High School in Hillsborough, and Chapel Hill attended the Mason Wagner Memorial Duals competition in Southern Pines.
Wrestling: Tigers go 3-1 at team tournament in Southern Pines
Chapel Hill made its way to Southern Pines on December 6 to make an appearance at the Mason Wagner Duals – a team tournament featuring multiple schools around the state. At the event, the Tigers challenged Central Academy of Technology and Arts, Gray’s Creek, Pinecrest, and Southern Lee, earning three victories over Central Academy of Technology and Arts, Gray’s Creek, and Southern Lee.
Against Central Academy of Technology and Arts, the Tigers cruised to a 57-18 victory. Elgia Helmstetter got it started for CHHS with a dominant 15-0 first round (1:53) triumph at 126 pounds over Dalton Helms. Jack Palmisciano followed for Chapel Hill with a 15-10 decision victory over Akhil Dhulipudi in the 132-pound match.
Later in the match Chapel Hill won six straight head-to-head matchups, as Jacob Rabinovitz earned an 8-0 major decision over Yandel Quizhpi at 144 pounds, Christian Garcia Mendez pinned Michael Chaprak in the first round (1:50) at 150 pounds, Troy Munday earned a 12-10 decision over Ziah Carnevale at 165 pounds, Samuel Monroe pinned Derek Minervini in just 18 seconds at 175 pounds, Troy Deniz pinned William Bolen in the first round (1:49) at 190 pounds, Benjamin Green pinned Liam Ramirez in 46 seconds at 215 pounds, and Owen Reams pinned Joseph Allred in just eight seconds at 285 pounds. Eliel Villedo added a third round (4:33) pin of Yash Mehendale in the 113-pound match, while Sergio Hewitt earned a forfeit at 157 pounds.
Against Gray’s Creek, Palmisciano gave Chapel Hill its first win with a 13-3 major decision victory over Caleb Salas in the 132-pound match. Rabinovitz pinned Luca Fedele in the first round (1:42) at 144 pounds, Garcia Mendez pinned Mason Nichol in just 11 seconds at 150 pounds, Hewitt earned an 18-2 technical fall in the third round (4:17) over Treven Tipton, and Munday pinned Meisner midway through the second round (2:59) at 165 pounds.
Later in the match the Tigers won four straight head-to-head battles, as Deniz pinned Alphonso Myers IV in the second round (2:40) at 190 pounds, Green earned a 3-1 extra time decision over Landon Cline at 215 pounds, Reams pinned Johnathan Hurlburt in 36 seconds at 285 pounds, and John Vece pinned Ethan Taylor in the second round (3:06) at 106 pounds. Helmstetter closed out the victory with a 19-2 technical fall win in the second round (3:33) over Kamron Placke at 126 pounds.
The Tigers got two victories in the match against Pinecrest, as Helmstetter earned a 6-1 decision over Jimmy Araujo, and Deniz pinned Davin Morris in the second round (3:28) at 190 pounds.
In the match with Southern Lee, Helmstetter earned a 21-2 technical fall win in the second round (2:49) over Erick Gutierrez at 126 pounds, Palmisciano pinned Julio Alvarez in 59 seconds at 132 pounds, Rabinovitz earned a hard-fought 8-7 decision win over Jakobe Griffin at 144 pounds, Garcia Mendez pinned Derek Elkins in 43 seconds at 150 pounds, Hewitt pinned Aaron Bolanos in the first round (1:42) at 157 pounds, Nicolaus Simms pinned Jordan Calderon in 38 seconds, Monroe pinned Gabriel Brooks in the first round (1:24) at 175 pounds, and Deniz pinned Aiden Donahoo in the first round (1:25) at 190 pounds.
Over the weekend, the Tigers will appear at the Beast of the East tournament on the campus of Croatan High School in Newport, near the Atlantic coast. Then on December 17, prior to the Holiday break, the Tigers will challenge Northern Durham at home in a dual team match.

CARRBORO JAGUARS
Men’s Basketball: Jags seeking redemption after slow start
Carrboros men’s basketball team was still seeking its first victory of the 2025-26 season as the Jaguars prepared to face off the evening of Friday, December 12 against Durham Riverside on the road. After suffering a 59-17 loss to Chapel Hill at home on the evening of December 5, the Jaguars slipped to 0-5 with an 57-42 loss to Crossroads Christian – again at home inside the CHS gymnasium – on December 6.
The Jaguars did have some bright spots despite the loss to Chapel Hill. CHS’s defense held the Tigers to just 43% shooting from the floor (24-of-56), while allowing just two made 3-pointers in 19 attempts (11%). Nonetheless, the Jaguars struggled themselves, scoring just 17 points in their fourth straight loss to begin the new season.
Carrboro played better offensively against Crossroads Christian – more than doubling their scoring output from the Chapel Hill game – but struggled to contain the visiting Colts, who overwhelmed the Jags with 34 first quarter points. Crossroads Christian led by a score of 55-19 at halftime, and then used a 19-9 run in the fourth quarter to continue running away from Carrboro. Junior Josh Smith led four players in double figures with 22 points in the win for Crossroads Christian.
Following the game December 12 at Durham Riverside, the Jags host Seaforth on December 16 and travel to South Granville December 19 as they begin play in the new Big Seven Conference.
Women’s Basketball: Jags looking to snap three-game losing streak
Carrboro’s women’s basketball team got off to a promising 2-1 start through its first three games, but now the Jaguars are looking to get back on track following a three-game losing streak. CHS lost 67-22 against Fayetteville Westover on November 22 leading up to a 53-21 loss at Northwood on December 2.
On December 5, the Jaguars traveled to Chapel Hill and came out on the wrong end of a 60-31 final score. The Jaguars hung tough early on, but eventually allowed the Tigers to run away from them. An 18-4 run in the second quarter proved devastating for the Jaguars, as they gave up a total of 27 steals to Chapel Hill’s defense in the 29-point setback.
On Friday, December 12, the Jaguars travel to Durham Riverside, followed by a home game December 16 against Seaforth and a road game at South Granville on Friday, December 19 as they begin play in the Big Seven Conference.
Wrestling: Matamoros wins 215-pound weight class for Jaguars
Carrboro had one wrestler place at the Jim King Invitational, a popular annual tournament held at Orange High School in Hillsborough on December 5 and 6. 215-pound standout Noah Matamoros ran the table and won the championship in his weight class. After receiving an opening-round bye, Matamoros earned a 14-6 major decision victory over Andrew Fayne.
In the semifinal round, Matamoros took on Dakota Rodriguez of Cape Fear. It was a tough battle that went the full six minutes, but Matamoros prevailed in a hard-fought 6-3 victory to advance to the championship match against Owen Chidester of Asheboro. In the final, Matamoros had to once again go the full three rounds. But again he endured, earning a decisive 5-1 triumph to take first place in his weight class.
EAST CHAPEL HILL WILDCATS
Men’s basketball: Wildcats dominate Cedar Ridge, fall to Fuquay-Varina
East Chapel Hill’s men’s basketball team split a pair of matchups December 5 and December 6, as Kennard Winchester’s squad earned a solid 52-34 victory over Cedar Ridge in Hillsborough on December 5, and then came home to suffer a disappointing 75-70 loss to Fuquay-Varina on December 6.
Against Cedar Ridge, the Wildcats overcame a sluggish offensive performance by protecting the ball and creating turnovers on the defensive end. While only committing eight turnovers all game, East Chapel Hill forced 15 Cedar Ridge steals, which led to numerous fast break opportunities for the Wildcats. East Chapel Hill also did a solid job on the boards, with a total of 32 rebounds. Those stats helped ECCHS offset a 38% shooting performance for the game (24-of-63).
Senior Jameer Phelmetta led the way for East Chapel Hill with 15 points on 7-of-12 shooting in the win to go along with six rebounds, while fellow senior William Hardin added eight points and.a team-high eight rebounds.
Returning home to face Fuquay-Varina, the Wildcats shot 38% from the floor for the second game in a row as they suffered a narrow five-point loss to the visiting Bengals. Fuquay-Varina connected on 11 3-pointers in the game, while forcing 16 East Chapel Hill turnovers. Despite the loss, ECHHS senior Frederick Rothert had a huge game for the Wildcats, scoring 24 points on 10-of-20 shooting, including four 3-pointers. Junior William Characklis added 17 points for East Chapel Hill, while Phelmetta had 13 points.
East Chapel Hill hosts Cedar Ridge Friday night in a home rematch with the Red Wolves. From there, the Wildcats travel to Southern Alamance on December 15 in their final game before the Holiday break.
Women’s Basketball: Wildcats eager to get into win column
East Chapel Hill’s women’s basketball team has had a wide variety of near-misses as they’ve gotten off to a disappointing 0-5 start. The Wildcats have suffered a series of single-digit losses to the likes of Green Hope, Carrboro, and Cedar Ridge – all winnable games that ECHHS had gotten had a few more shots fallen, and had a few more stops been attained on defense.
East’s latest heartbreak was a 34-28 loss at home to non-conference foe Cedar Ridge on the evening of December 5. The Wildcats struggled offensively, making just 19 percent of their shots (10-of-53), and just one 3-pointer in 14 attempts (7%). Despite this, the aggressive East Chapel Hill defense collected 14 steals and were in the game all the way down to the final minutes. But some costly turnovers down the stretch – part of 23 for the game by the Wildcats – led to the team’s fifth straight loss to start the season.
Sophomore Evelyn Drecktrah led East Chapel Hill with 10 points in the narrow loss, while fellow tenth grader Alison Zaranek added six points.
East Chapel Hill goes after its first victory – and some redemption against Cedar Ridge – as the Wildcats travel to Hillsborough to face the Red Wolves in a rematch the evening of Friday, December 12.
Wrestling: Wildcats beat South Garner, appear at Jim King Invitational
On December 2, prior to their appearance at the Jim King Invitational in Hillsborough, East Chapel Hill challenged South Garner in a non-conference dual team match. ECHHS came away with a 40-35 victory in the showdown.
The Wildcats had a stretch of five straight head-to-head victories over South Garner midway through the match, which ultimately paved the way to victory for East Chapel Hill. Noah Finken pinned Anderson Cantor in the first round (1:25) at 132 pounds, Cole Shuster pinned Eduardo Cedillo in the first round (1:37) at 138 pounds, Shane Shuster pinned Julius Jones in the first round (1:01) at 144 pounds, Ben Nabedrik pinned Zavad Davis in 44 seconds at 150 pounds, and Hogan Martin earned a 9-1 major decision over Pierce Day at 165 pounds. Two other Wildcats – Omar Al Mosawa at 126 pounds and Ezekiel Neff at 157 pounds – earned victories by way of forfeit.
At the Jim King Invitational, East Chapel Hill had two placers, as Cole Shuster finished in second place in the 138-pound weight class, and Shane Shuster placed third for the Wildcats in the 144-pound weight class.
In the 138-pound bracket, Cole Shuster followed up an opening-round bye with a first round pin (1:12) of Casey Yamauchi of Durham Jordan in the second round. In the quarterfinals, Shuster dominated Trey Trollinger of Southeast Alamance in another first round fall (1:13). Then in the semifinals, Shuster took down Omar Rushing of Western Alamance in a pin late in the third round (5:48).
In the championship final, Shuster took on Tye Johnson of Cape Fear. Shuster lost a 20-5 major decision in the third round (4:42), but overall it was a solid performance for the East Chapel Hill 138-pound talent.
In the 144-pound bracket, Shane Shuster followed up a first round bye with a second round pin (3:15) of Haydn Driver. Shuster was absolutely dominant in the quarterfinal round, as he put together a 15-0 shutout technical fall midway through the second round (3:00) over Gavin Smith of Western Alamance.
In the semifinals, Shuster was pinned in the first round by Samuel Gantt of Pine Forest, which relegated him to the consolation bracket. But after a forfeit victory, which advanced him to the third place match, Shuster got another victory to close out the weekend. Challenging Dalton Gardner of South Davidson, Shuster earned an 18-1 technical fall win in the third round (5:00) for the third place medal.
On Thursday, December 11, East Chapel Hill traveled to Northern Durham for a dual team match, earning a solid 66-12 victory. The Wildcats won a total of five head-to-head matchups against the Knights, as Matthew Son pinned Rider Dowdall in the second round (3:21) at 120 pounds, Cole Shuster pinned Matthew Davis in the second round (3:50) at 138 pounds, Neff pinned William Gardner late in the second round (3:51), Hogan Martin pinned Rhys Clayton in the second round (2:33), and Josiah Whitesell pinned Andrew Harris in the third round (4:25). ECCHS also got forfeit wins from Roland Owen at 113 pounds, Al Mosawa at 126 pounds, Shane Shuster at 144 pounds, Kaine Matak at 175 pounds, Benjamin Goldstein at 215 pounds, and Samuel Chorino at 285 pounds.
Over the weekend, the Wildcats will make their way to Raleigh to appear in the Rumble in the Jungle Tournament at the Carolina Pines Community Center.
Adam Powell has been a correspondent for The Local Reporter since 2023. A 2001 graduate of UNC-Chapel Hill, Powell has served as managing editor of multiple local publications, including the News of Orange County, the Mebane Enterprise, the Caswell Messenger, and the ACC Sports Journal. The author of four books. Adam currently resides in Mebane with his wife Julie and children Colt and Jenna. This reporter can be reached at:Information@TheLocal Reporter.press







Be the first to comment on "High School Sports Notebook: Wrestling Triumphs, Local Rivalry Basketball Matchups"