OWASA completes Parkline Village East analysis for sewer capacity

COMMUNITY NEWS

By Adam Powell
Correspondent

CHAPEL HILL–OWASA’s Engineering Manager for Development Services, Jessica Godreau, came before the OWASA Board of Directors on the evening of January 9 to explain the unique circumstances of Chapel Hill’s Parkline Village East project, which was adopted last April as a component of the Town of Chapel Hill’s Complete Community Strategy. 

Town leaders in Chapel Hill are seeking a more urban dynamic, with mass transit and walkability increasingly taking precedence over driving and commuting. However, with more urban development comes more density and, subsequently, more strain on the overall capacity of the town’s sewer and water infrastructure. 

Meridian Lakeview, Chapel Hill Crossing, Old Chapel Hill Apartments, and East Lakeview Townhomes are proposed projects along Old Chapel Hill Road as part of Parkline East Village.

In addition, OWASA’s Knolls Pump Station is slated for upgrades within the OWASA capital improvement plan (CIP). However, upgrades are not necessary to that pump station to serve the four Parkline Village East projects, according to OWASA officials.  

“What we do is we work with the development community through permitting and construction of projects before the assets are dedicated to OWASA to own and maintain,” said Godreau. “A key objective for OWASA is to prepare for the growth that the local governments are planning, and we are given their development expectations over time. That gets incorporated into our sewer capacity model.”  

OWASA engineer breaks down sewer capacity modeling process for community

Godreau explained that the current OWASA collection system model includes critical sewer mains and large underground pipes that collect wastewater from residential and commercial properties. 

The sewer capacity model includes 12-inch or more prominent water mains, some 8-inch water mains, and OWASA’s Pump Stations. It is based on 2018 data and managed by consultants on behalf of OWASA. 

“So in that model, our service area is divided into about 240 little sub-catchment areas that we analyze for the model,” explained Godreau. 

Subcatchment areas are small spaces within a larger catchment that drains to a single point. They are used to model water flows in specific places around Chapel Hill, such as the proposed areas of Parkline East Village. 

“The model shows us where our collection system is going to be challenged to meet the expected future flows that the local governments planned for, and then that serves as an initial input to our capital improvement program (CIP) prioritization process,” explained Godreau further. “And other projects that don’t have anything to do with the model can be added to the CIP. That model serves as the initial basis we use for our planning.”

Godreau indicated that OWASA staff compares the anticipated wastewater flows generated by that project to the model output for proposed projects, seeking to recognize disparities that could raise questions about future infrastructure capacity concerns. 

“If the growth is within what was planned and expected for that subcatchment area and within that timeframe, then the capacity analysis is typically complete. When the flows for a project are above what is expected for the sub-catchment area or is faster than the local governments had projected it to happen, a model run is needed to see how our system will respond to that additional wastewater flow,” Godreau stated. 

In other words, OWASA needed to do more sewer infrastructure wastewater modeling to ensure that Parkline East Village’s long-term sewer capacity would be adequate. Those models have previously been funded by developers looking to create a new project, but OWASA recently changed its policy on requiring developers to pay for the modeling.

“Historically, that model run has been paid for by the developer asking that question. So, the new model might show sufficient capacity within our existing infrastructure for that project if our capital improvement program is implemented as planned. Or it may show that some critical mains need to be upsized.” 

OWASA changes policies on who pays for capacity modeling

Godreau explained to the OWASA board that developers have paid three times for that analysis to be completed in her six years with the organization. In each instance, OWASA had the necessary capacity, requiring no additional system upgrades. 

But she qualified that those were individual projects – not a multi-development project such as Parkline East Village. 

“All of those (previous models) have been single projects in a sub-catchment area, though,” Godreau indicated. 

OWASA has a policy requiring the first developer to develop a specific location to pay for the necessary water and sewer infrastructure, including installing the water/sewer mains and essential connections to existing lines when applicable. 

The multiple large residential projects within Parkline East Village have created confusion and concern for developers about who will ultimately pay for these installations.

“So when there isn’t enough capacity, what happens, and who pays?” Godreau said. “So all new water and sewer main extensions that we have to meet the needs of a specific project are paid for by the developer who wants and needs those services. Other projects may come along after and benefit from those main extensions.”

According to Godreau, OWASA’s capital improvement plan considers upgrading the collection system to accommodate the town’s planned growth. However, the model does not include growth that the local governments didn’t anticipate. 

“So if the model run shows that upgrades are needed for a project, OWASA creates a special project and includes that in our CIP prioritization process,” Godreau explained. “And that gets measured against all the other utility needs that we have. We do that analysis on an annual basis. The developer then has the option of either letting the CIP program and process carried out while waiting for those improvements to happen or if they don’t happen within the time frame that they need it, then they pay for those improvements themselves.” 

Analysis indicates OWASA has the capacity for Parkline Village East.

Last week, OWASA staff confirmed to The Local Reporter that the Parkline Village East sewer capacity model analysis has been completed. The January model run indicated that the OWASA collection system currently has adequate sewer capacity to support the four Parkline Village East projects. No additional upgrades beyond those already identified in OWASA’s capital improvement plan are needed.

Godreau added that OWASA currently has an excess capacity credit policy. This policy states that if OWASA mandates that a water main line be upsized to accommodate future development needs that aren’t part of the specific project being requested by a developer, the costs are recovered from the future projects that connect to the original water mains. However, this is only when mains are upsized—not regular projects that don’t require future upgrades. 

“Costs are recovered from the future projects that connect to (the original project) and recover for about 10 years. But that’s only if the mains are upsized,” she added. “If I build that main and somebody else connects onto it in the future, there’s no cost recovery that happens for that.”

Godreau acknowledged the unique circumstances of four large-scale residential projects coming together in roughly the same geographic area within roughly the same time frame. 

While indicating that this is a new situation for OWASA, Godreau said they anticipate seeing more of it in the coming years and decades as Chapel Hill constructs more missing middle housing and urban-style developments. 

“We have a really unusual situation where we have four concurrent projects, which combined exceed that wastewater flow for that sub-catchment area that has been modeled past 2035,” she said. “So we have areas that have not been modeled that we have questions about the localized impact of the wastewater flow in that area that need to be answered. So this type of situation – with multiple concurrent projects – hasn’t come up at OWASA before. So this is kind of a new concept of how do we deal with this kind of issue? Although with things like the southern boundary area expansion and going out and into the country more, we think we will see more of this kind of situation where we have concurrent projects in a sub-catchment area.”

Godreau added that OWASA had conducted internal discussions to figure out the best path moving forward – which led to OWASA choosing to fund future modeling tests instead of requiring developers to pay. 

“In mid-December, OWASA made a major change to our process,” she explained. “We have decided that OWASA will pay for the model runs for these types of analyses moving forward, instead of making the developers do it. It’s something that we (OWASA) should be doing, to be understanding the capacity of the system and ability of developers to connect to that.” 

Godreau, on behalf of OWASA, contacted the four existing Parkline East Village projects in mid-December, informing them of the status and current schedule of the modeling tests and letting them know that OWASA has questions about potential sewer infrastructure capacity concerns in the area. The current modeling was scheduled to be completed in late January. 

“We have no policy or process for how we might (allocate costs among multiple projects,)” she continued. “So if the model shows that some upgrades are needed – and we don’t know that it will show that – but if the model shows that some updates are needed, we have no policy or process that would say how do we allocate those costs among multiple projects?”

“The way it’s always been is just whoever comes in when capacity is needed, they build the lines,” she added. “Other projects that come after get to benefit from that. But there’s not something that says if (developer) A comes in on Monday and there is capacity, and (developer) B comes in on Tuesday, and they cross the (sewer capacity) threshold, and now there’s not capacity anymore, so (developer) B has to do all that improvement. And then (developer) C comes in and they get the free ride too. And that’s how it’s worked, (but) the projects have always been spaced out in time, much more than this. We don’t even know which of these projects are going to be approved first, so we’ve really been struggling with how do we deal with this kind of issue when we don’t know that there’s the capacity?”

“So the first step is doing this model run, and seeing whether or not we do have an issue,” Godreau said as she concluded her presentation to the OWASA board. 

“So they will run the model in terms of the existing critical infrastructure that we have, and they’ll also be adding the primary mains up these routes that the wastewater will be coming in to us to see whether or not we do have any capacity issues or not. And if we do, then I had suggested in my message to people in December that we have a meeting with all four of these projects and get together and talk about what their needs are. Talk about what their timing is, what their expectations are, and see if there’s a more equitable way of just saying whoever is the one that’s the project there the wrong day, is the one that pays the full cost. Because if they’re not having to upsize anything, that excess capacity credit policy wouldn’t come into play. And just whoever that project is, is the one that’s going to bear the full cost of whatever upgrades might be needed to accommodate that waste flow. So that’s our current process.” 

OWASA Board of Directors members inquire about new policies

Following Godreau’s presentation, OWASA Board of Directors member Elmira Mangum expressed concerns about the future costs of modeling tests by consumers rather than developers, who typically have millions of dollars to spend on their various residential projects. 

Mangum questioned why OWASA was choosing to ease the burden of the modeling costs on developers. This will ultimately increase water/sewer utility costs for residents and business owners. 

“I have a question about the decision that you guys came to have OWASA absorb the cost rather than the developers,” Mangum inquired. “So basically, that’s part of the rate structure that everybody else is going to pay for. How did you guys rationalize having everybody pay for it rather than a developer pay for it? Because I’m sure you could come up with various models to have distributed that cost across developers in the future, rather than having the customers pay for the development cost for developers.” 

“That’s where we started. The conversation is to say with these four (Parkline East Village) projects, how would we allocate that modeling cost?” Godreau said in response to Mangum’s questions. 

“How did you get back to the customers when we’ve got a 15% rate increase already?” Magnum said back to Godreau. “Is that included in it? I mean, how did you get to the everyday customer paying for developments project?” 

“We determined that we think that it’s OWASA’s responsibility to understand the capacity of our system and the ability of people to connect,” said Godreau. 

“You were translating the customer – the everyday customer – into OWASA, when the people that use water are the people that are actually paying every month when they get their bill,” said Mangum. “That’s what I don’t get.That’s a question about rationalization of passing a developer’s cost on to the customer when the developer can surely afford to pay it.”

Another OWASA Board of Directors member – Susana Dancy – inquired as to whether OWASA had been conducting sensitivity analysis across its network to determine how changes in circumstances such as inflow rates, pipe diameters, and/or slope and soil conditions could affect the area’s infrastructure capacity over time. 

“I’m trying to understand where the sensitivity analysis is – if there is any sensitivity analysis to our system,” Dancy inquired. “Do we have areas of town that are reaching capacity where we haven’t looked at what are the assumptions going into this? Because I can tell you that the town council made the decision in their future land use map, more than five years ago, that this (Parkline Village East area) was going to be a high growth area. And prior to that, it was supposed to be part of the light rail stop and going to be a high growth area for that. So I’m trying to figure out how we as a utility have been caught flat-footed? I’m just trying to figure out, how do we not have this happen again? Where there’s a mismatch of what the expectations of the town is, and what our (OWASA’s) understanding of what’s expected of us is. I’m trying to figure out where that lack of information is why that’s happening? I am trying to understand how we as a public utility are not ready when, when this has been public information for a long time.”

“It’s a slow process, based on planning studies and planning documents and models, and it’s not designed to turn on an annual basis,” Godreau explained in response to Dancy. “We update our model about every 10 year frequency now, and it’s an expensive and time-consuming process.” 

Board Member Todd BenDor disagreed with Dancy’s assessment that OWASA wasn’t ready for the proposed infrastructure needs at Parkline Village East, suggesting that it was more of a question of who would pay for the necessary infrastructure installations as opposed to whether OWASA could handle the extra capacity. 

“So it’s not actually clear to me that we’re not ready,” BenDor stated. “Ready for what? There’s nothing there (at this point in time). This is a matter of installing upgrades to infrastructure that could be done relatively quickly. It’s just the question of who pays. So my question would be, actually, what is legal here? You’re essentially talking about, like an OWASA impact fee, where you’re distributing the costs across many to-be users that don’t exist yet.”

“Will the decision that is made on this project set a precedent for other similar projects into the future,” asked OWASA Board member Johnny Randall. 

“If there’s upgrades that are needed, those conversations, I think, will help evolve how we do things,” said Godreau. “We’ve never had this situation before, so we’re going to have to figure it out.” 

“So long as we exist, we will probably continue to grow,” said Mangum. “And if we establish a precedent that the community at large – the OWASA community – is going to pay for growth and development and expansion, because if more people move in, water capacity changes, needs change. Does that mean the rate structure is going to continually change for the growth and development? I think it’s a bad precedent to set, and I think we need to revisit their strategy, because there are lots of strategies for distributing cost, and it doesn’t always have to include a rate increase to the customer, and it’s going to continuously happen. It’s already a concern for me right now, and I know we’re going to continue to grow because we are a popular area.”

“We’ll probably not figure all that out in time to address this particular situation (at Parkline Village East),” said OWASA Executive Director Todd Taylor. “I just want to make sure that it’s fine with us moving ahead with this, because developers out here need answers from us. We need to move forward with it, and our intent here is to try and make this as fair as possible. You’ve got four different projects. If we follow our current policy, whichever ones we can fit in the sewer, whoever gets there first, they get the capacity, and the others will be on the hook for the upgrades. If there are (future) improvements, possibly there’s a sharing amongst the developers, but the policy we currently have is first come, first serve.”


Adam Powell is a reporter on local news and sports and an education communications professional. A 2001 graduate of UNC-Chapel Hill, Powell has served as managing editor of multiple local publications, including the Mebane Enterprise, News of Orange County and TarHeelIllustrated.com. The public information officer for Rockingham County Schools in Eden, N.C., Powell is the author of four books and lives in Mebane with his wife and two children. This reporter can be reached at: Information@TheLocal Reporter.press.

Share This Article

Scroll down to make a comment.

2 Comments on "OWASA completes Parkline Village East analysis for sewer capacity"

  1. Julie McClntock | February 6, 2025 at 10:12 pm | Reply

    This article is chock full of good information! It’s taken years following UNC’s sale to the community, for OWASA to arrive at fair charges. Growth costs the community! It is much fairer to charge the developer for the additional costs. Constituent governments should object! A former OWASA chair

  2. Current customers should NOT have to pay for the costs of sewer infrastructure wastewater modeling for future possible developments.
    As said, a 15% increase already exists for current customers.
    There must be a way for developers to share the cost involved; otherwise, continue as is…with developers footing the bill.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*