GOVERNMENT
By Fraser Sherman
Correspondent
CARRBORO –“If you’ve ever tried to tell the guy cleaning your grease trap at 6 AM that he can’t come in your building right now, it doesn’t go well,” Tesoro’s David Peretin told the Carrboro Town Council Oct. 7. That, Peretin said, was one of the problems with the council’s tentative plan to turn East Weaver Street into a pedestrian mall.
The council heard a presentation on the proposal at the last meeting in June, but postponed action until the fall. Tuesday, the councilors agreed they needed more information before attempting to ban cars from Weaver Street.
The East Weaver dream
East Weaver Street is a single 650-foot-long block between Greensboro Street and Main Street. It includes Weaver Street Market, the Carr Mill parking lot, Century Center, the town’s police station, and several local businesses. Closing it to cars, the council members have said, would create a pedestrian- and bicycle-friendly downtown area and could also encourage more people to leave their cars and arrive by bus, bike, or on foot.
City staff’s Oct. 7 presentation said they’d spent the summer talking to the community about the idea. Among the pluses people listed, the pedestrian mall would add charm and a sense of community, offer greater safety for patrons at Weaver Street Market, and improve downtown social life. Reservations also included the impact on traffic congestion, delays in emergency services, the effect on bus routes, and ADA access.
The finished plan would include lane restripings and an adjusted stop bar at one intersection. A service lane/designated bike lane would provide access for delivery and emergency vehicles, while removable metal bollards would block the road to most traffic.
Business worries
“Weaver Street is how a lot of residents go home in the evening,” commercial landlord Grace Holton told the council, “and come to work in the morning.”
Holton said she rents out several properties around the East Main/Greensboro intersection and worries that the congestion if East Weaver closes will discourage customers from patronizing her tenants.
Spotted Dog owner Ed Corbell said he worried people wanting to walk up and down E. Weaver would park in nearby lots and end up being towed. He also questioned how the bollards would work: what happens when someone shows up in the middle of the night to make a delivery? Is he supposed to ensure that all the 30 or 40 vendors he deals with have the key to remove the bollards?
Corbell, like several other speakers, said that closing the street on weekends and evenings might work, but during the daytime on Mondays through Fridays, it would pose serious problems. Peretin noted that profit margins, even for a successful restaurant, are so thin that even a 10% drop in customers would be fatal.
Traffic and transit
Several speakers expressed their appreciation for this plan, describing it as wonderful and long overdue. Others cited traffic as a concern — would it clog up other nearby intersections if cars couldn’t drive up E. Weaver? Council Member Catherine Fray said the city’s study indicated queuing would become shorter at most intersections because of changes to the turn lanes and the light cycles. “We’re not doing this in ignorance of the effects on traffic. We’re doing this in large part because we want to resolve problems with traffic.”
Transit was another issue. Eliminating the E. Weaver pedestrian stop would eliminate the stops there, and Chapel Hill Transit has said it might have to reduce or relocate some of its downtown stops. Eliazar Posada-Orozco said that disabled residents rely on buses to get around, including when visiting downtown non-profits that provide services. If the stops were moved even a couple of blocks, that would cut off those residents from help, and the town might not know for sure until after they’d closed E. Weaver. Posada-Orozco said he’d need to know that wasn’t going to happen before he could support the plan.
Fire Chief Will Potter said he suspected Chapel Hill Transit had some of the same concerns he did. Navigating a busy intersection in a large vehicle is hard, particularly when there’s a driver shortage and a lot of people behind the wheel are new — “the biggest turn they’ve made is in a Honda Accord.” The Fire Department’s drivers already have problems because when vehicles move past intersection stop bars before they come to a complete stop, it’s impossible to maneuver a fire truck past them.
Despite the town’s push for feedback from residents and business owners, some speakers said they hadn’t reached out enough. Mayor Barbara Foushee said that was one of the most significant issues for her: many people used downtown or drove through the area, and it appeared that many of them would have no idea what was coming until they faced the E. Weaver bollards.
The council discussed whether they could launch a pilot project, for example, closing the road on one Sunday a month. The counter-argument was that closing on a weekend wouldn’t test the higher downtown traffic during the work week. Planner Duncan Dodson said they’d also be looking at traffic under current conditions, without any of the proposed changes to road striping or intersections.
Foushee said the project has no current deadlines, so there’s no need to move fast. Dodson said staff would work to gather more feedback from residents and discuss their concerns with businesses, then report back to the council.
You can watch the entire meeting streaming on YouTube.
Fraser Sherman has worked for newspapers, including the Destin Log, the Pensacola News-Journal and the Raleigh Public Record. Born in England, he’d still live in Florida if he hadn’t met the perfect woman and moved to Durham to marry her. He’s the author of several film reference books and has published one novel and several short story collections. This reporter can be reached at: Information@TheLocalReporter.press






Be the first to comment on "Town Council Wants More Answers Before Banning Cars From Weaver Street"